Code: Select all
+-------------+--------------------+--------------------+---------+
|Author |Title |Feedback |Score |
+-------------+--------------------+--------------------+---------+
| nyxeles |Dancing In The Dark | Harmonies+++ | 3 |
+-------------+--------------------+--------------------+---------+
| MyLoFy | Tubawub+Brolka | New genre+++ | 4 |
+-------------+--------------------+--------------------+---------+
| a-lin | Huscendance | Hookiness++++ | 5 |
+-------------+--------------------+--------------------+---------+
Some more in depth feedback:
@nyxeles
Your harmonies are great and recognizable! They crystallize being one of your signature musical elements! I like the loudness and energy-wise dynamics between parts and that the melody keeps chaining. However, a break/pause with predominately atonal/percussive elements might help to bring the energy is bit down and built some tension for the next hook. I am not sure about the intro. I would start right away around 0:36.
@MyLoFy
Pioneering in establishing Brolka as the next big thing. Super cool When the Polka sections kicked in I was like and .
Production and sound design are - as always - top notch! You deserve a 5 for sure but sry, this time asublin caught me a bit more.
Extra kudos for developing every of your 37 SurgeXT instances from Init!!
@asublin
Dude, this is just super catchy with a great melody. Also the your SurgeXT patches are super sweet and support the catchiness a lot!
The nifty detail, that makes the difference to me is e.g. at 1:09 - 1:10 were a very short one is leading into the main melody note. I would have used a pitched bend. Your short note works far better
My only critique: The first third. The contrast to the hook is great, however some bass or some anticipation of the hook might help to catch your listeners even earlier!