Libre Music Challenge #6 : Lullabies !

Practical tips for recording, editing, and mastering.

Moderators: khz, MattKingUSA

Senbee
Established Member
Posts: 20
Joined: Wed Aug 29, 2018 10:40 pm
Location: Italy
Contact:

Re: Libre Music Challenge #6 : Lullabies !

Post by Senbee »

Code: Select all

Calm and Sleepy        | MyLoFy              | 3.5
For the Lullsaby       | Vulnr               | 3.5
Infinite Lullaby       | Unfa                | 5
Lullaby                | Erk                 | 3
Lullaby for Good Sleep | A-Lin               | 4
Music Box              | Senbee              | 
Ramshackle Lullaby     | Pulsing Bulb        | 5
Sweet Dreams           | a.very              | 3.5
Torchbearer (Lullaby)  | Fusterclucker       | 3
Fais Dodo Louise       | Lèyon di li Neûris′ | 3
Lydian Lullaby         | dr4co               | 4

MyLoFy - Calm and Sleepy - Nice sounds, I like it's so ethereal. It doesn't change so much, though.
Vulnr - For the Lullsaby - Same as "Calm and sleepy", but: 1) I like less the sounds, 2) it's good there are more changes
Unfa - Infinite Lullaby - The most original of all ones, really new to my ears, perfect calm but suspended atmosphere, a real lullaby in a far future, and a lot of experimentation (random generator! WOW!!!)
Erk - Lullaby - Sorry, it's surely my fault but I can't understand this kind of extreme minimalistic experimentation
A-Lin - Lullaby for Good Sleep - After the first minute, it becomes a Bach composition and I adore it. It's wrong to make it a lullaby, if it were without dynamics, only organ, it would have been perfect.
Pulsing Bulb - Ramshackle Lullaby - Love the rarefied atmosphere, the floating dissonances.
a.very - Sweet Dreams - Not so original, but this is a real lullaby.
Fusterclucker - Torchbearer (Lullaby) - I really appreciate the work on vocals, but maybe this is not a lullaby at all.
Lèyon di li Neûris′ - Fais Dodo Louise - Very nice sound, very nice initial idea, but it's clear the author didn't have time to develop it properly so it didn't blossom, it sounds kind of unfinished.
dr4co - Lydian Lullaby - Beautiful suspended atmosphere, I love it.
I'm a SUDO wrestler - Italy - Ubuntu 20.04 - Ardour 6.6 - www.stefanodroghetti.it - www.youtube.com/user/SenbeeNorimaki - www.soundcloud.com/stefano-droghetti
0xdebe
Posts: 2
Joined: Wed Sep 30, 2020 1:59 pm

Re: Libre Music Challenge #6 : Lullabies !

Post by 0xdebe »

These are my scores.

Code: Select all

TITLE                    ARTIST             SCORE

Calm and Sleepy        | MyLoFy            | 5
For the Lullsaby       | Vulnr             | 3
Infinite Lullaby       | Unfa              | 4
Lullaby                | Erk               | 3
Lullaby for Good Sleep | A-Lin             | 2
Music Box              | Senbee            | 4
Ramshackle Lullaby     | Pulsing Bulb      | 2
Sweet Dreams           | Avery             | 5
Torchbearer (Lullaby)  | Fusterclucker     | 2
Fais Dodo Louise       |Lèyon di li Neûris′| 3
Lydian Lullaby         | Draco             | 3

Code: Select all

TITLE                    ARTIST             COMMENT

Calm and Sleepy        | MyLoFy            | Pros: Realistic Lullaby. I like the wave feeling
                       |                   | Cons: IMHO pads are too "pumping out" to be a lullaby

For the Lullsaby       | Vulnr             | Pros: less boring
                       |                   | Cons: I think it's better on a sci-fi movie :-D

Infinite Lullaby       | Unfa              | Pros: I like the wave feeling
                       |                   | Cons: there's a strange noise/break in the middle. I don't like it (it's a lullaby, no?)

Lullaby                | Erk               | Pros: I like the heartbeat.
                       |                   | Cons: I don't like the out of tune progression. I feel it disturbing.

Lullaby for Good Sleep | A-Lin             | Pros: I like some of the arpeggios
                       |                   | Cons: bass are too booming. I think you need more legato. 

Music Box              | Senbee            | Pros: I like the aco guitar.
                       |                   | Cons: Maybe the voice is too present related to "music box". 

Ramshackle Lullaby     | Pulsing Bulb      | Pros: Interesting atmosphere. 
                       |                   | Cons: personally i don't like the "out of metric", but it can work for a lullaby.

Sweet Dreams           | Avery             | Pros: Remind me a christmas song... :-D. i like it! The final 
                       |                   | Cons: Some of the staccato on bass part seems out of the groove.

Torchbearer (Lullaby)  | Fusterclucker     | Pros: Interesting vox mix
                       |                   | Cons: I think didn't work as lullaby: there are too many start/stop.

Fais Dodo Louise       |Lèyon di li Neûris′| Pros: Nice sound. 
                       |                   | Cons: Not resolving on final part. Maybe it works on loop?

Lydian Lullaby         | Draco             | Pros: i like the ethreal mood
                       |                   | Cons: as for Vulnr, I think it's better on a sci-fi movie :-D. 

I tried to write, in cons part, what I don't feel right for a lullaby. Technically speaking all the pieces are beyond me.
I think i'll try some of the pieces with my "third baby on the way" :D
User avatar
Lèyon di li Neûris′
Established Member
Posts: 58
Joined: Wed Dec 09, 2020 12:10 am
Location: County of Hainaut where people should speak walloonish. Integrated to something called: “Belgium”.
Contact:

Re: Libre Music Challenge #6 : Lullabies !

Post by Lèyon di li Neûris′ »

0xdebe wrote: Thu Jan 21, 2021 8:47 amNot resolving on final part.
I tried my best to resolve it by keeping the concept of notes tied to lyrics, I lowered the note that I had to keep for that reason and that go against the resolution (resolution that the other notes do), maybe I should lower it more, I don't know if that would really make the trick or maybe I will try to find another idea for the final, I don't know and I have even less time now to work on it.
0xdebe wrote: Thu Jan 21, 2021 8:47 amMaybe it works on loop?
Yes and no: what is before the final might be looped, but the final is the final.
Excuse my not so bad imperialist language.
Je parle:
-français (langue maternelle),
-ein bisschen Deutsch,
-on topau walon,
-een beetje Nederlands,
-je signe peu la langue des signes de Belgique francophone,
-я чуть чуть говорю по-русски,
-a trochu česky.
User avatar
MyLoFy
Established Member
Posts: 12
Joined: Sat Jun 27, 2020 8:10 am

Re: Libre Music Challenge #6 : Lullabies !

Post by MyLoFy »

Hey there, awesome submissions! That makes voting a bit tricky, so I randomly voted how close it is to a lullaby in my understanding:

Code: Select all

TITLE                    ARTIST             SCORE

Calm and Sleepy        | MyLoFy            | X
For the Lullsaby       | Vulnr             | 3 Cool piece, I found it more stimulating than calming
Infinite Lullaby       | Unfa              | 3 Great randomization concept! Relaxing backgound sound carpet, but I wouldn't perceive it as a lullaby
Lullaby                | Erk               | 2 Nice sounds though the detuning doesn't give much sleepy coziness
Lullaby for Good Sleep | A-Lin             | 4 Love the composition and E-Piano sound 
Music Box              | Senbee            | 5 Composition, performance, lyrics, all spot on!
Ramshackle Lullaby     | Pulsing Bulb      | 3 Could be cozier
Sweet Dreams           | Avery             | 5 All cliches met, very assuring and calming melody. And moog-like sounds always win my approval ;)
Torchbearer (Lullaby)  | Fusterclucker     | 2 Like the vocals and mix, though not very lullabish (look at me - inventing new words!)
Fais Dodo Louise       |Lèyon di li Neûris′| 2 Good draft, could be developed into a nice tune
Lydian Lullaby         | Draco             | 3 Great sounds, mix and idea, could be more comforting to make a baby fall asleep 
That was great fun, I'm looking forward to the next challenge!
Sahaathyva
Established Member
Posts: 28
Joined: Sun Nov 29, 2020 6:01 pm

Re: Libre Music Challenge #6 : Lullabies !

Post by Sahaathyva »

Hey friends, after a semi dozen listenings here is my ranking :

Code: Select all

Calm and Sleepy        | MyLoFy              | 3
For the Lullsaby       | Vulnr               | 3
Infinite Lullaby       | Unfa                | 3.5
Lullaby                | Erk                 | 3
Lullaby for Good Sleep | A-Lin               | 5
Music Box              | Senbee              | 5
Ramshackle Lullaby     | Pulsing Bulb        | 3
Sweet Dreams           | a.very              | 4
Torchbearer (Lullaby)  | Fusterclucker       | 2
Fais Dodo Louise       | Lèyon di li Neûris′ | 3
Lydian Lullaby         | dr4co               | 3.5
As already said before , content is great i'm a bit ashamed not having time to finish my try @ a lullaby ... i hope i will manage to finish this project,
if you want i will share with you if i finish it :cry:

Voting was really hard, so i put my personnal feelings in the balance.

i'm very busy at the moment , so did not have that enough time to write any comments, if you want i can give my toughts , just ask and be patient :D

I'm sincerly proud of you contributors and the content you gave : @Lèyon di li Neûris′ i would be happy to hear a finished version of that lullaby , @Fusterclucker : sadly off topic but i like that raw material, is the "real" mix available somewhere to listen to ?

@asublin and @Senbee : you reached my musician heart ;)
User avatar
Lèyon di li Neûris′
Established Member
Posts: 58
Joined: Wed Dec 09, 2020 12:10 am
Location: County of Hainaut where people should speak walloonish. Integrated to something called: “Belgium”.
Contact:

Re: Libre Music Challenge #6 : Lullabies !

Post by Lèyon di li Neûris′ »

Sahaathyva wrote: Thu Jan 21, 2021 9:15 pmif you want i will share with you if i finish it :cry:
Yes, I want!
Sahaathyva wrote: Thu Jan 21, 2021 9:15 pmi would be happy to hear a finished version of that lullaby
As soon as I have time, I'll finish it and post all (the final result in FLAC file format and the Ardour session it some kind of free / libre compressed file).
Excuse my not so bad imperialist language.
Je parle:
-français (langue maternelle),
-ein bisschen Deutsch,
-on topau walon,
-een beetje Nederlands,
-je signe peu la langue des signes de Belgique francophone,
-я чуть чуть говорю по-русски,
-a trochu česky.
User avatar
dr4co
Established Member
Posts: 6
Joined: Wed Sep 30, 2020 6:42 pm
Contact:

Re: Libre Music Challenge #6 : Lullabies !

Post by dr4co »

I finally got around to listening... here are my scores:

Code: Select all

TITLE | ARTIST | SCORE

Calm and Sleepy 	| MyLoFy 		| 5
For the Lullsaby 	| Vulnr 		| 3
Infinite Lullaby 	| Unfa 			| 5
Lullaby 		| Erk  			| 2
Lullaby for Good Sleep 	| A-Lin 		| 3
Music Box 		| Senbee 		| 4
Ramshackle Lullaby 	| Pulsing Bulb 		| 2
Sweet Dreams 		| Avery  		| 5
Torchbearer (Lullaby) 	| Fusterclucker		| 1.5
Fais Dodo Louise 	| Lèyon di li Neûris′ 	| 3
Lydian Lullaby 		| Draco 		| X
a.very
Established Member
Posts: 3
Joined: Sat Jan 02, 2021 9:31 pm

Re: Libre Music Challenge #6 : Lullabies !

Post by a.very »

I revised these multiple times, because each time I listen I feel that there is a song that I rated too low in comparison, and I'd give it an extra 0.5. So I better stop here otherwise you'll all end up with 5 points :)

Code: Select all

Calm and Sleepy        | MyLoFy              | 5   -- best in category: "theme"
For the Lullsaby       | Vulnr               | 3.5
Infinite Lullaby       | Unfa                | 3.5
Lullaby                | Erk                 | 2.5
Lullaby for Good Sleep | A-Lin               | 4.5 
Music Box              | Senbee              | 5   -- best in category: "composition"
Ramshackle Lullaby     | Pulsing Bulb        | 3
Sweet Dreams           | a.very              | X
Torchbearer (Lullaby)  | Fusterclucker       | 2.5
Fais Dodo Louise       | Lèyon di li Neûris′ | 3
Lydian Lullaby         | dr4co               | 4
Sahaathyva
Established Member
Posts: 28
Joined: Sun Nov 29, 2020 6:01 pm

Re: Libre Music Challenge #6 : Lullabies !

Post by Sahaathyva »

We got the results !

Code: Select all

TITLE ARTIST SCORE AVERAGE RANK

Calm and Sleepy | MyLoFy | 43,5 | 3,625 | 3
For the Lullsaby | Vulnr | 39 | 3,25 | 6
Infinite Lullaby | Unfa | 39,5 | 3,3 | 5
Lullaby | Erk | 30 | 2,5 | 11
Lullaby for Good Sleep | A-Lin | 40,5 | 3,375 | 4
Music Box | Senbee | 46,5 | 3,875 | 1
Ramshackle Lullaby | Pulsing Bulb | 31 | 2,59 | 9
Sweet Dreams | A.very | 44 | 3,67 | 2
Torchbearer (Lullaby) | Fusterclucker | 31 | 2,59 | 9
Fais Dodo Louise |Lèyon di li Neûris′| 31,5 | 2,625 | 8
Lydian Lullaby | Draco | 36 | 3 | 7
@Senbee wins, but as he made an outrageous cheat, he did not want to win the eternal fame over audio linux community, so! :

The winner is @a.very !!!

Congratulations , all subs were quality works, i'm so happy all of those musicians took a part and that some non challengers of LM forum did a vote ;)

Stay tuned as i will open the #07 LMC soon !

And again a big CONGRATULATIONS to @a.very and you all #06 Challengers, i hope to see you in the next challenge
Senbee
Established Member
Posts: 20
Joined: Wed Aug 29, 2018 10:40 pm
Location: Italy
Contact:

Re: Libre Music Challenge #6 : Lullabies !

Post by Senbee »

Sahaathyva wrote: Sun Jan 24, 2021 8:01 pm
@Senbee wins, but as he made an outrageous cheat, he did not want to win the eternal fame over audio linux community, so! :

Exactly! I didn't read properly the rules, so I put effects on single tracks. If I won, I'd feel like stealing the title to people who respected the rules, so I agree the real winner is @a.very!
I'm a SUDO wrestler - Italy - Ubuntu 20.04 - Ardour 6.6 - www.stefanodroghetti.it - www.youtube.com/user/SenbeeNorimaki - www.soundcloud.com/stefano-droghetti
User avatar
Lèyon di li Neûris′
Established Member
Posts: 58
Joined: Wed Dec 09, 2020 12:10 am
Location: County of Hainaut where people should speak walloonish. Integrated to something called: “Belgium”.
Contact:

Re: Libre Music Challenge #6 : Lullabies !

Post by Lèyon di li Neûris′ »

It looks like some votes are not in the forum. So, where are they?
Excuse my not so bad imperialist language.
Je parle:
-français (langue maternelle),
-ein bisschen Deutsch,
-on topau walon,
-een beetje Nederlands,
-je signe peu la langue des signes de Belgique francophone,
-я чуть чуть говорю по-русски,
-a trochu česky.
Senbee
Established Member
Posts: 20
Joined: Wed Aug 29, 2018 10:40 pm
Location: Italy
Contact:

Re: Libre Music Challenge #6 : Lullabies !

Post by Senbee »

Lèyon di li Neûris′ wrote: Mon Jan 25, 2021 1:35 pm It looks like some votes are not in the forum. So, where are they?
Here: https://discord.com/channels/3445420728 ... 0439164004
I'm a SUDO wrestler - Italy - Ubuntu 20.04 - Ardour 6.6 - www.stefanodroghetti.it - www.youtube.com/user/SenbeeNorimaki - www.soundcloud.com/stefano-droghetti
Sahaathyva
Established Member
Posts: 28
Joined: Sun Nov 29, 2020 6:01 pm

Re: Libre Music Challenge #6 : Lullabies !

Post by Sahaathyva »

The challenge comes from Unfa's chatroom , we share there so we are more to have fun ;)

If you want i will try for the next challenge to post the chat votes overthere,you can trust me i've been fair in the ranking ( took me some serious minutes yesterday :mrgreen: ).

And BTW i put results on 1st post but i'm not good enough to put the ascii spreedsheet in right form, if someone can do this favor to me that would be better :)
User avatar
Lèyon di li Neûris′
Established Member
Posts: 58
Joined: Wed Dec 09, 2020 12:10 am
Location: County of Hainaut where people should speak walloonish. Integrated to something called: “Belgium”.
Contact:

Re: Libre Music Challenge #6 : Lullabies !

Post by Lèyon di li Neûris′ »

Thank you, but I don't have a discord acount and I don't want to have one, I think there was something like rocket-chat tied to it, I'll dig about that when I'll have the time.
Sahaathyva wrote: Mon Jan 25, 2021 8:17 pmIf you want i will try for the next challenge to post the chat votes overthere,you can trust me i've been fair in the ranking ( took me some serious minutes yesterday :mrgreen: ).
I trust you, I mean, I don't trust any human (not even myself), but, for that, I trust you. I just wanted to understand how it works.
Sahaathyva wrote: Mon Jan 25, 2021 8:17 pmAnd BTW i put results on 1st post but i'm not good enough to put the ascii spreedsheet in right form, if someone can do this favor to me that would be better :)
You just need to look at it in a text editor. Here it is:

Code: Select all

Title                  | Artist              | Score | Avarage | Rank
Calm and Sleepy        | MyLoFy              | 43,5  | 3,625   | 3
For the Lullsaby       | Vulnr               | 39    | 3,25    | 6
Infinite Lullaby       | Unfa                | 39,5  | 3,3     | 5
Lullaby                | Erk                 | 30    | 2,5     | 11
Lullaby for Good Sleep | A-Lin               | 40,5  | 3,375   | 4
Music Box              | Senbee              | 46,5  | 3,875   | 1
Ramshackle Lullaby     | Pulsing Bulb        | 31    | 2,59    | 9
Sweet Dreams           | A.very              | 44    | 3,67    | 2
Torchbearer (Lullaby)  | Fusterclucker       | 31    | 2,59    | 9
Fais Dodo Louise       | Lèyon di li Neûris′ | 31,5  | 2,625   | 8
Lydian Lullaby         | Draco               | 36    | 3       | 7
But i prefer in this order:

Code: Select all

Artist              | Title                  | Score | Avarage | Rank
MyLoFy              | Calm and Sleepy        | 43,5  | 3,625   | 3
Vulnr               | For the Lullsaby       | 39    | 3,25    | 6
Unfa                | Infinite Lullaby       | 39,5  | 3,3     | 5
Erk                 | Lullaby                | 30    | 2,5     | 11
A-Lin               | Lullaby for Good Sleep | 40,5  | 3,375   | 4
Senbee              | Music Box              | 46,5  | 3,875   | 1
Pulsing Bulb        | Ramshackle Lullaby     | 31    | 2,59    | 9
A.very              | Sweet Dreams           | 44    | 3,67    | 2
Fusterclucker       | Torchbearer (Lullaby)  | 31    | 2,59    | 9
Lèyon di li Neûris′ | Fais Dodo Louise       | 31,5  | 2,625   | 8
Draco               | Lydian Lullaby         | 36    | 3       | 7
This is even more beautiful:

Code: Select all

 _______________________________________________________________________
| Artist              | Title                  | Score | Avarage | Rank |
|_____________________|________________________|_______|_________|______|
| MyLoFy              | Calm and Sleepy        | 43,5  | 3,625   | 3    |
| Vulnr               | For the Lullsaby       | 39    | 3,25    | 6    |
| Unfa                | Infinite Lullaby       | 39,5  | 3,3     | 5    |
| Erk                 | Lullaby                | 30    | 2,5     | 11   |
| A-Lin               | Lullaby for Good Sleep | 40,5  | 3,375   | 4    |
| Senbee              | Music Box              | 46,5  | 3,875   | 1    |
| Pulsing Bulb        | Ramshackle Lullaby     | 31    | 2,59    | 9    |
| A.very              | Sweet Dreams           | 44    | 3,67    | 2    |
| Fusterclucker       | Torchbearer (Lullaby)  | 31    | 2,59    | 9    |
| Lèyon di li Neûris′ | Fais Dodo Louise       | 31,5  | 2,625   | 8    |
| Draco               | Lydian Lullaby         | 36    | 3       | 7    |
|_____________________|________________________|_______|_________|______|
But it adds a scrollbar, so maybe this is better (even if there is still a scrollbar):

Code: Select all

 _______________________________________________________________________
| Artist              | Title                  | Score | Avarage | Rank |
| MyLoFy              | Calm and Sleepy        | 43,5  | 3,625   | 3    |
| Vulnr               | For the Lullsaby       | 39    | 3,25    | 6    |
| Unfa                | Infinite Lullaby       | 39,5  | 3,3     | 5    |
| Erk                 | Lullaby                | 30    | 2,5     | 11   |
| A-Lin               | Lullaby for Good Sleep | 40,5  | 3,375   | 4    |
| Senbee              | Music Box              | 46,5  | 3,875   | 1    |
| Pulsing Bulb        | Ramshackle Lullaby     | 31    | 2,59    | 9    |
| A.very              | Sweet Dreams           | 44    | 3,67    | 2    |
| Fusterclucker       | Torchbearer (Lullaby)  | 31    | 2,59    | 9    |
| Lèyon di li Neûris′ | Fais Dodo Louise       | 31,5  | 2,625   | 8    |
| Draco               | Lydian Lullaby         | 36    | 3       | 7    |
|_____________________|________________________|_______|_________|______|
You can also order by rank:

Code: Select all

 _______________________________________________________________________
| Artist              | Title                  | Score | Avarage | Rank |
|_____________________|________________________|_______|_________|______|
| Senbee              | Music Box              | 46,5  | 3,875   | 1    |
| A.very              | Sweet Dreams           | 44    | 3,67    | 2    |
| MyLoFy              | Calm and Sleepy        | 43,5  | 3,625   | 3    |
| A-Lin               | Lullaby for Good Sleep | 40,5  | 3,375   | 4    |
| Unfa                | Infinite Lullaby       | 39,5  | 3,3     | 5    |
| Vulnr               | For the Lullsaby       | 39    | 3,25    | 6    |
| Draco               | Lydian Lullaby         | 36    | 3       | 7    |
| Lèyon di li Neûris′ | Fais Dodo Louise       | 31,5  | 2,625   | 8    |
| Pulsing Bulb        | Ramshackle Lullaby     | 31    | 2,59    | 9    |
| Fusterclucker       | Torchbearer (Lullaby)  | 31    | 2,59    | 9    |
| Erk                 | Lullaby                | 30    | 2,5     | 11   |
|_____________________|________________________|_______|_________|______|
Idem:

Code: Select all

 _______________________________________________________________________
| Artist              | Title                  | Score | Avarage | Rank |
| Senbee              | Music Box              | 46,5  | 3,875   | 1    |
| A.very              | Sweet Dreams           | 44    | 3,67    | 2    |
| MyLoFy              | Calm and Sleepy        | 43,5  | 3,625   | 3    |
| A-Lin               | Lullaby for Good Sleep | 40,5  | 3,375   | 4    |
| Unfa                | Infinite Lullaby       | 39,5  | 3,3     | 5    |
| Vulnr               | For the Lullsaby       | 39    | 3,25    | 6    |
| Draco               | Lydian Lullaby         | 36    | 3       | 7    |
| Lèyon di li Neûris′ | Fais Dodo Louise       | 31,5  | 2,625   | 8    |
| Pulsing Bulb        | Ramshackle Lullaby     | 31    | 2,59    | 9    |
| Fusterclucker       | Torchbearer (Lullaby)  | 31    | 2,59    | 9    |
| Erk                 | Lullaby                | 30    | 2,5     | 11   |
|_____________________|________________________|_______|_________|______|
By the way, do not trust me, I might have changed the results :wink: :P.
Excuse my not so bad imperialist language.
Je parle:
-français (langue maternelle),
-ein bisschen Deutsch,
-on topau walon,
-een beetje Nederlands,
-je signe peu la langue des signes de Belgique francophone,
-я чуть чуть говорю по-русски,
-a trochu česky.
a.very
Established Member
Posts: 3
Joined: Sat Jan 02, 2021 9:31 pm

Re: Libre Music Challenge #6 : Lullabies !

Post by a.very »

<Award ceremony mode on> :)

What an honor!

I'd like to thank everybody involved in this challenge, but especially:

@Senbee, for giving up his first place, your song was a masterpiece

@unfa, for the excellent Ardour-tutorials

@Sahaathyva, for organising this challenge.

So thank you, grazie, dziękuję, merci, danke, gråces, bedankt, ...
and hope to see you all back in one of the next challenges!
Post Reply