Libre Music Challenge #5: Halloween

Practical tips for recording, editing, and mastering.

Moderators: khz, MattKingUSA

nilshi
Established Member
Posts: 349
Joined: Wed Oct 22, 2008 9:05 pm
Contact:

Re: Libre Music Challenge #5: Halloween

Post by nilshi »

Scoring Sheet:

Code: Select all

+---+----------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------+-------+
|   | Artist                     | Track                                                     | Score |
+---+----------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------+-------+
| 1 | nilsh /Neal Sky            | The Witch, the Skeleton, and the Alien from Zorblax IV    |float("inf") | Next time I try to mix and master!
+---+----------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------+-------+
| 2 | AnyThreeWords/Jesse Pender | Harvested                                                 |   1   | Sorry, I don't like the patchwork and dry sound.
+---+----------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------+-------+
| 3 | unfa                       | Halloweiner                                               |   2   | Solid production, but not much Halloween
+---+----------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------+-------+
| 4 | MyLoFy                     | Fritz The Creepy Goldfish                                 |   4   | Mallets and Robo-Voice. What can go wrong? Nothing. 
+---+----------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------+-------+
| 5 | Pulsing Bulb               | Pat, Carla, Jack and Yoshimi versus the Ghosts from Space |   2   | Stockhausen-Sound is the wrong kind of horror.
+---+----------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------+-------+

User avatar
MyLoFy
Established Member
Posts: 9
Joined: Sat Jun 27, 2020 8:10 am

Re: Libre Music Challenge #5: Halloween

Post by MyLoFy »

Here are my scores:

Code: Select all

+---+----------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------+-------+
|   | Artist                     | Track                                                     | Score |
+---+----------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------+-------+
| 1 | nilshi/Neal Sky            | The Witch, the Skeleton, and the Alien from Zorblax IV    |   5   | Best approach for the theme, all clichés fulfilled. Great!
+---+----------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------+-------+
| 2 | AnyThreeWords/Jesse Pender | Harvested                                                 |   4   | Guitars! I like guitars!
+---+----------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------+-------+
| 3 | unfa                       | Halloweiner                                               |   3   | Cool track, but the least creepy :)
+---+----------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------+-------+
| 4 | MyLoFy                     | Fritz The Creepy Goldfish                                 |   X   |
+---+----------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------+-------+
| 5 | Pulsing Bulb               | Pat, Carla, Jack and Yoshimi versus the Ghosts from Space |   4   | Great sound design! Love the full frequency spectrum, also it's nicely balanced. Not creepy enough though
+---+----------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------+-------+

User avatar
turbidh20
Established Member
Posts: 188
Joined: Sun Aug 04, 2019 12:48 pm
Location: UK

Re: Libre Music Challenge #5: Halloween

Post by turbidh20 »

I thought I'd posted this but it never appeared, so here goes again...

Code: Select all

+---+----------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------+-------+
|   | Artist                     | Track                                                     | Score |
+---+----------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------+-------+
| 1 | nilshi/Neal Sky            | The Witch, the Skeleton, and the Alien from Zorblax IV    |   4   | Nice "Addams Family" style vibe.
+---+----------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------+-------+
| 2 | AnyThreeWords/Jesse Pender | Harvested                                                 |   4   | Got a "video game" vibe, nice use of the "vocals", liked the guitar part.
+---+----------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------+-------+
| 3 | unfa                       | Halloweiner                                               |   3   |  More techno than Halloween for me.
+---+----------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------+-------+
| 4 | MyLoFy                     | Fritz The Creepy Goldfish                                 |   4   |  Great title! Couldn't quite make out all the words though. Bit of a classic Halloween music vibe.
+---+----------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------+-------+
| 5 | Pulsing Bulb               | Pat, Carla, Jack and Yoshimi versus the Ghosts from Space |   3   |  A good "disturbing" vibe but too long and repetitive for me.
+---+----------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------+-------+
Well done to everyone who contributed, a great effort all round :D
Arch Linux (i7-4790k/GTX970); UMC204HD; MPK Mini MKII; Jack2 (QjackCtl) & Ardour/Mixbus

User avatar
MyLoFy
Established Member
Posts: 9
Joined: Sat Jun 27, 2020 8:10 am

Re: Libre Music Challenge #5: Halloween

Post by MyLoFy »

And here they are, the final votes. That means Halloween is now officially over!

Code: Select all

+----------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------+--------+--------+--------+-----------+-------+
| Artist                     | Track                                                     | nilshi | MyLoFy | zwenny | turbidh20 | Total |
+----------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------+--------+--------+--------+-----------+-------+
| nilshi/Neal Sky            | The Witch, the Skeleton, and the Alien from Zorblax IV    | X      | 5      | 4      | 4         | 9     |
+----------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------+--------+--------+--------+-----------+-------+
| AnyThreeWords/Jesse Pender | Harvested                                                 | 1      | 4      | 2      | 4         | 7     |
+----------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------+--------+--------+--------+-----------+-------+
| unfa                       | Halloweiner                                               | 2      | 3      | 3      | 3         | 8     |
+----------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------+--------+--------+--------+-----------+-------+
| MyLoFy                     | Fritz The Creepy Goldfish                                 | 4      | X      | 4      | 4         | 8     |
+----------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------+--------+--------+--------+-----------+-------+
| Pulsing Bulb               | Pat, Carla, Jack and Yoshimi versus the Ghosts from Space | 2      | 4      | 3      | 3         | 9     |
+----------------------------+-----------------------------------------------------------+--------+--------+--------+-----------+-------+
Congrats to nilshi and Pulsing Buld for sharing the LMC halloween throne :)

And don't forget to submit your lullaby for the next challenge!

Post Reply